Over the summer I wrote a blog series about emotional regulation in a polarizing social-political climate. I explored why we react with big emotions, ways to self-regulate when activated, how to listen when we’re outside of our comfort zone, and the impact of community on our nervous systems. As I’ve reflected on those posts I realized that I was not clear on one point: that emotional regulation is not the same as being calm.
Many of us absorbed the notion that being good at handling emotions means being unbothered or unfazed when disruption occurs. We think that a person who has an anger flare, grief swell, or anxiety buzz is out of control and doing something wrong and only consider someone to be emotionally mature if they can stay level in a crisis, never raise their voice, and find peace in all situations.
But that’s not actually regulation. That’s just the appearance of being calm. And the two are very different things.
What Regulation Actually Is
Emotional regulation is the ability to notice what you’re feeling, understand what the emotion is telling you, and respond in a way that fits the situation and your values. It’s about your relationship with your emotions, not the absence of them.
A regulated person can feel furious and still choose not to send the scathing email. They can feel terrified and still walk into the hard conversation. They can cry at a funeral, shake with excitement before a big moment, or feel a surge of irritation in a meeting and decide what to do with it. The feeling is allowed to exist. Regulation is what happens next.
Calm, on the other hand, is just one emotional state among many. It’s a fine emotion and nothing is wrong with it per se, but treating it as the goal turns every other feeling into a problem to be fixed.
The Trouble With “Keep Calm And Carry On”
When calm becomes the target, a few things tend to happen.
Emotional suppression becomes valued. Pushing a feeling down can look like composure from the outside, but suppressed emotions don’t actually disappear. They leak out. It might look like tension in the body, irritability over small things, numbness, or sudden outbursts that seem out of proportion. Research on emotional suppression has been repeatedly linked to higher physiological stress and strained relationships, even when the person appears fine.
Information is lost. Emotions give us data. Anger can signal that a boundary has been violated. Sadness tells us we’re hurt. Anxiety helps us protect what we care about. Fear alerts us to danger. When we quiet these signals, we lose access to the very information that helps us know ourselves and navigate our lives with meaning.
Our relationships are flattened. Relationships rely on emotional honesty. When we hide our frustrations, hurts, and/or needs it becomes hard to know ourselves and even harder for others to know us. This can leave emotional distance between our partners, friends, and family; children raised in a household where being calm is the only acceptable state, learn that big feelings are dangerous.
Why Range Matters
Emotions are a set of tools, each one does a different job.
Someone with access to a whole toolbox can better respond to whatever life throws at them. In contrast, someone with a limited range of tools may have to make do with whatever they have access to. This is the person who meets grief with a shrug and a joke or the person who meets every disappointment with rage or, at the opposite end of the spectrum like Pollyanna, is compelled to find the silver lining.
Psychologists sometimes call this emotional granularity: the ability to distinguish between feelings with precision, such as being able to tell the differences between disappointment, resentment, embarrassment, and overwhelm. People with higher granularity tend to cope better with stress because naming a feeling accurately points toward what it needs and feeling an emotion helps it become integrated.
Normalizing Our Responses
When we accept our emotions as a natural response to our environment and our circumstances, we are better poised to discern how to respond. We feel less shame about our reactions which allows us to see our experience more honestly and therefore, think more clearly.
The goal isn’t a life without emotional weather, but becoming someone who can stand in the rain, read the sky, and decide what to do next. Calm will come and go, but your capacity to feel and to respond with care is what actually carries you through.
So, the next time you catch yourself thinking “I shouldn’t be this upset,” try asking something different: What is this feeling trying to tell me, and what do I want to do about it?
If you find you can’t feel much at all or if your emotions regularly feel unmanageable, know that it’s not a personal failing. Patterns, like trauma responses or depression, on top of social pressures to stay calm can make regulation genuinely harder. If you’d like to build your capacity to feel a wider range of emotion, send us a note, we’d be happy to help.
